Influencing Senior Executives: The Bigger Picture Behind Every Decision

What looks entirely rational from where you stand can look absurd from one level up.

Anyone influencing upwards faces the same task. Understand the senior person well enough to move them. What matters to them, what they are trying to achieve, what pressure they are under.

Capable people do this reasonably well. The stronger ones go a step further. They understand the boss of the person they are influencing, and shape the argument around what is being demanded from above.

Even that can leave important forces outside the field of view. Understanding the boss and their boss still covers only part of the decision environment. Forces that sit beyond the reporting line shape a decision long before it reaches any meeting. By the time it arrives, it is already formed.

Two views of one decision

A proposal that looks entirely rational from one position can look absurd from another. Irrational, political or obstructive is the usual verdict from below. The reviewer is simply looking at a different picture.

That picture contains pressures the proposer cannot see. Priorities set elsewhere. Changes under way in other parts of the organisation. Commitments made to people further up that have not been announced.

Each of these is invisible from below, and each shapes the answer.

Pressure from outside

The higher the position, the more of that pressure originates beyond the organisation. Markets move. Technology changes what is possible. Regulation alters the constraints. Competitors change the economics. Political and geopolitical developments shift priorities. Assumptions that held for years quietly stop holding.

Boards, investors, regulators and customers press on those at the top in ways that rarely reach the people below. What does reach them arrives as instruction, with the reasoning stripped out.

Why the gap widens

Seniority changes the balance. Lower down, understanding the territory immediately around the role is usually enough. Higher up, it is insufficient. Each step upward adds forces to the picture, and each force changes what a decision means for the person making it.

This is where Domain Mastery extends beyond expertise. It is command of the wider territory in which a role operates, including its actors, dependencies and external forces. An executive or senior expert holding that wider view reads a decision differently. The territory that matters stops at no organisational boundary.

What the gap costs

The cost is rarely visible. A proposal receives polite interest and no sponsor. A recommendation is acknowledged and shelved. The proposer concludes that the idea was weak, or the audience unreceptive.

But there is another possibility. The idea met a landscape it was never built for.

Judgement and influence

The same view does two jobs. It improves influence, because an argument can be placed where it fits the decision maker’s actual situation.

It also improves judgement. The person who sees more of the landscape understands why a decision is being taken, what changes it, and where their own position sits within it.

The missing perspective

The proposer sees a sound case. The decision maker sees that case alongside everything else pressing on them.

The evidence can be strong and the presenter credible. The decision still goes elsewhere, for reasons that were never part of the conversation.

The two views rarely meet.

Colin Gautrey, October 2026

Further insights:

Colin Gautrey writes extensively for senior professionals repositioning in a new world.

Political Dexterity: The Capability That Decides What Survives

The critical gap people refuse to name. Some senior professionals have it. None of them got it from a training programme. And the gap it leaves is now deciding which organisations, and careers, survive.

Read more


Defining Astute Judgement: The Capability Uncertainty Demands

The concept, its foundations, and what it requires. It is not intuition. It is not analysis. It is not executive decision-making. Astute judgement is a precise and learnable capability that operates where all three run out.

Read more


Why Rational Argument Fails: The Case for Political Dexterity

The influence habit that worked until it didn’t. Senior experts built their power on knowing more than the room. That power is eroding. They can no longer ignore the capability they avoided for decades.

Read more